05 December 2019
New Delhi: As RBI maintained status quo on the repo rate in the last monetary policy of the current calender on rising inflation fears, most rating agencies, broking houses and industry bodies were jolted on Thursday at the belying of their predictions of a rate cut.
They had predicted that the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) would cut its repo, or short term lending rate for commercial banks, in view of the dismal second quarter GDP growth rate of 4.5 per cent.
Emkay Wealth Management Head of Research Joseph Thomas noted three reasons for the RBI not cutting rates this time.
First, the retail inflation numbers as represented by the consumer price index (CPI) has shot up to 4.62 per cent, well above the RBI median target of 4 per cent. The component affecting the price level is fruits and vegetables, which he considers a seasonal factor whose impact may wane over the next one or two months.
Secondly, the rupee is weaker currently than it was three months ago. A weaker rupee is akin to lower interest rates. Since the rupee is expected weaken further, a repo cut may not be the best thing this juncture since, effectively a lower rate is already prevailing with a weaker rupee.
Thirdly, both liquidity in the inter-bank market and systemic liquidity are in surplus and there is sufficient liquidity to see the auctions go through smoothly. The liquidity conditions ensure that rates, especially those at the short end of the curve, remain low.
"This is what is actually achieved by a repo rate cut too. Therefore, a cut was not required at this juncture," Thomas saqid in a note.
Fitch Group subsidiary India Ratings and Research (Ind-Ra), however, believes the evolving growth inflation dynamics provides room for rate cut,
"The RBI perhaps has been guided by three factors. Firstly, a 25 bp (basis points) rate cut today would have meant policy repo rate declining to 4.90, thereby leaving very little head room for further monetary action. Secondly, retail inflation showing a rising trend since February 2019, and thirdly, to allow more time for the transmission of past rate cuts to seep into the economy," said Ind-Ra Principal Economist Sunil Kumar Sinha.
"Under the current environment when both business and consumer sentiments are down a rate cut alone will not spur consumption and/or investment demand," he added.
ICRA Principal Economist Aditi Nayar said: "In what came as a surprise to the markets, the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) chose to pause rather than cut rates for a sixth consecutive time. Above-target inflation and incomplete transmission outweighed the sharp cut in the GDP growth forecast, prompting the pause from the MPC."
"The reiteration that the stance will remain accommodative for as long as necessary to revive growth signals that this is not the end of the rate cut cycle. However, the next rate cut will only be forthcoming when there is clear visibility that the headline CPI inflation will revert below 4 per cent," she added.
Nikhil Gupta, Chief Economist, Motilal Oswal said: "Overall, today's status quo increases the credibility of RBI's inflation mandate. We had always believed that today's cut would be the last rate cut in this cycle. We continue to maintain that there will be no more rate cuts now unless inflation falls back towards 4 per cent."
Kotak Equities said the repo rate remained unchanged as there is not much flexibility on the inflation targeting framework.
"We believe that recent inflation prints have taken precedence over the growth concerns. In fact, seemingly, the RBI is pushing the onus of growth support to the government. Further, the RBI wants to wait-and-watch the effect of the government's measures and RBI's past rate cuts," Kotak said.
"More than flare in inflation, lack of transmission of rate cut seems to have been the bigger reason for the rate pause. We, however, expect RBI to resume rate cut in January 2020. We also expect fiscal 2020 GDP growth to be better than RBI's revised estimate", said Sujan Hajra, Chief Economist and Executive Director, Anand Rathi Shares & Stock Brokers.
Rajan Bandelkar, President, NAREDCO Maharashtra and Managing Director, Raunak Group said: "In the past also, the advantage of the rate cut by the RBI was not passed onto the customers by a majority of the banks, which impacted the growth of the real estate sector. In the given situation, the RBI should not just look at the repo rate revision, but instead, take a holistic approach. It must consider an important area like the restructuring of realty loans, as well as, reintroducing of subvention schemes. It must take steps to streamline much-needed financing into the sector."
Edelweiss Securities Lead Economist Madhavi Arora said that this easing pause is temporary.
"In a situation when growth slowdown looks more entrenched and underlying core inflation has slumped to sub-3.5 per cent amid widening output gap, the monetary accommodation still has further steam for another 50 bps in this rate cut cycle."
President and Head Of Research at Yes Securities Amar Ambani said: "Given the growth-inflation dynamics, we still sense that RBI will deliver a rate cut of 25 bps in the February policy meeting given the widespread deceleration in the economy.
"Although RBI is concerned about near-term inflation risks, higher Rabi crop output will assuage the spike in food prices. Benign core-inflation will also persuade RBI to remain accommodative."